Where to Find the Best Sticky Toffee Pudding in Newcastle
Satisfy that sweet tooth with our round-up of the Toon’s best sticky toffee pudding
January 23rd is International Sticky Toffee Pudding Day and we’re here to help you find and feast upon the most delicious of desserts.
Though the origins of sticky toffee pudding are debated – some say it was invented in Cumbria, some say Canada, others say Aberdeenshire – there’s no doubt that it’s Britain’s best-loved dessert and us Geordies are lucky enough to have many delicious options right here in the heart of Newcastle.
Read on to find out where to try the best sticky toffee pudding in the Toon to enjoy on January 23rd and beyond.
Blackfriars, Friars Street
Soak up some history and some delicious sticky toffee pudding in the 13th century friary-turned-restaurant that is Blackfriars. Served with a sumptuous salted caramel sauce and refreshing banana ice cream (pictured above), it’s often hailed as the best sticky toffee pudding in all of Newcastle so it’s a must-try for lovers of the classic dessert. It’s gluten-free too!
Pleased To Meet You, High Bridge
Drizzled with salted caramel sauce, topped with crushed hazelnuts and served with bourbon vanilla ice cream, Pleased To Meet You’s sticky toffee pudding is heaven on a plate. Book up for their afternoon tea and you can enjoy mini versions with their sticky toffee bites alongside an array of other sweet and savoury treats too.
Tomahawk, Quayside
Tomahawk might be best known for its steaks, but don’t sleep on its deliciously indulgent sticky toffee pudding! Served with toffee sauce and black treacle-flavoured ice cream, it’s ideal paired with one of Tomahawk’s after dinner cocktails or liqueur coffees.
Heavenly Desserts, Newgate Street
You’re sure to be in heaven with a trip to Heavenly Desserts to try their sticky toffee pudding. They keep classic, serving with a rich toffee sauce and creamy custard and people following a plant-based diet are in luck too as there’s a tempting vegan version teamed with toffee sauce, hot custard and honeycomb.
Aveika, Sandhill
For a less traditional take on sticky toffee pudding, head to Aveika where the classic dessert gets a Japanese twist by throwing miso into the mix and serving with a soy miso toffee sauce teamed with vanilla ice cream. It’s also available as part of their Asian-inspired Sunday lunch menu.
Leila Lily’s, Grey Street
Leila Lily’s buck the vanilla ice cream trend by instead serving their indulgent sticky toffee pudding with homemade tonka bean ice cream, giving the classic dessert a delightfully aromatic and slightly spicy edge. Make sure to check out their signature cocktails while you’re there – we reckon the Cherry Drop or Lady in Red would make a great accompaniment.
Creams, Grainger Street
A mecca for sweet treats, Creams goes all out with its sticky toffee pudding which comes with both custard and salted caramel gelato and is topped with toffee sauce, Speculoos biscuit crumbs and a wafer. Wash down with one of their Hot GeLatte drinks for the ultimate indulgence.
Victors, Quayside
Victors’ gorgeous floral interior makes for the perfect backdrop to enjoy its equally gorgeous sticky toffee pudding. Complemented by salted toffee sauce, Biscoff and salted caramel ice cream, it’s vegan and vegetarian-friendly so nobody has to miss out on the sticky toffee pudding fun.
Babucho, Side
Quayside brasserie Babucho keeps it simple yet delicious, serving its sticky toffee pudding with butterscotch sauce and vanilla ice cream – the perfect finish to a meal of its mouthwatering Italian cuisine. It’s suitable for vegetarians and there’s a gluten-free option available too, while little ones can enjoy a smaller version with sticky toffee bites from Babucho’s kids’ menu.
Miller & Carter, Mosley Street
What better way to end a delicious steak dinner at Miller & Carter than with sticky toffee pudding for dessert? Simple yet classic, they serve theirs with vanilla bean ice cream and sticky pickled desserts. Why not wash it down with one of their dessert wines for a special treat?
No doubt your taste buds are tempted by all the delicious sticky toffee pudding waiting for you in Newcastle, so go forth and feast and let us know which one is your favourite!~
Main image: Blackfriars
Want to be in the know about everything that’s happening in Newcastle city centre? Sign up to our newsletter and follow us on Facebook, Instagram, X and TikTok.
